Thursday, February 2, 2017

Post 10

Cover 1
Characteristics: The focal point of this cover is a Caucasian blonde girl sitting in a vegetated area with a sad and possibly thoughtful expression on her face. The font of the title and author are both small and capital letters, but the title is slightly larger. It includes accolades such as the Man Booker Prize and a review from The New York Times.
Intended Purpose:  This cover implies that the book takes a melancholic tone and is possibly about a girl seeking in the secluded forest since she is alone and centered on the cover, appearing as if she is deep in thought.
Reason:  Focus on the main character and her feelings about her struggles


Cover 2
Characteristics:  This cover includes an ambiguous girl, possibly Asian, who is possibly fleeting. The background is yellow, which alludes to safety and warmth, which contrasts form the title and action of the girl. The author and title are in a large font, but the author's name is larger and more centered on the cover. It includes accolades such as the Man Booker Prize, a review from Observer, and Top Ten Bestseller.
Intended Purpose:  This cover implies that the book is perhaps about a child who is fleeing, based on the blurred image. Though it also puts importance on the author since the font of his name is larger than the title and centered.
Reason:  Focus on the journey of the main character

Cover 3
Characteristics:  This cover pictures a white boat tied to a pole in a desolate pond. It has a dreary, yellow tint to it which is similar to Sepia, which alludes to the past and possibly a memory. The emotion depicted is sad because the boat is alone with no people near it and everything seems very still and calm. The font of the author and title are slightly large, though the focus is on the author's name. It includes accolades such as the Man Booker Prize and a review from Time.
Intended Purpose:  This cover implies that the book is sad and depicts loneliness since it pictures a lone boat on a pond, which could also represent the internal struggle of a main character.
Reason:  Focus on the desolate setting in which the story takes place

Cover 4
Characteristics:  This cover shows a child-like drawing of  organs inside a barbed wire body with a window picturing trees faintly in the background. The emotion revealed is one of fear since the paper is "trapped" inside the window. The font of the title is large and scrawled, covering a lot of area on the cover, which differs from the author's name which is small and included on the bottom of the cover.
Intended Purpose:  This cover attempts to create a mysterious tone for the novel through scrawled handwriting and a child-like drawing of internal organs surrounded by barbed wire. This depiction implies that someone may be trapped.
Reason:  Focus on the mystery of the novel, while slightly connecting the the health aspect of the novel, with things such as donors and carers.

Similarities:
Cover 1 and Cover 2 both picture a young adult female on the cover. Cover 1 is similar to Cover 3 because both integrate an outdoor setting that insinuates loneliness. Cover 1 and Cover 4 both picture forests and vegetation while showing a sad tone. Also, they both have a focus on the title in comparison to the author. Cover 2 and Cover 3 both have a yellow tint to the background and have the font of the author larger than the title. Cover 2 and Cover 4 both have connections to the idea of being trapped or wanting to escape. Cover 3 and Cover 4 both refrain from including images of people.

A Closer Examination:
Cover 1
At first glance, this cover conjures the words "alone," and "hidden". It makes me think of the feelings you experience when one bad thing happens to you that makes you just want to separate yourself from the world for awhile.

If I saw this cover before I read Never Let Me Go, it would make me think the book was about a lost girl in a rural or magical place. But because I have read the book, I believe the image is meant to represent Kathy H. at Hailsham and how she has many wonders about the secrets of the location.

This cover seems to portray the main character, Kathy H., from possibly the perspective of someone who does not attend Hailsham and disapproves of the project going on there, thus explaining why the girl on the cover appears sad and hidden away.

This cover places the book in a Westernized cultural setting. The teenage girl pictured, appears to be dressed modestly without makeup, implying that she is innocent.

I think the cover was made by a European, particularly British, company. I think this because it follows the English archetype of innocent female characters in need of help. Also, since the author lives in England, he most likely has a large English following.

Cover 2
Cover 2 makes me think of the words "child," and "escape". It appears that the person on the cover is running from the photographer because they are either scared or sad. Running away from problems is most connected to children.

Before reading, this cover would make me think the book is about a child who is unhappy and trying to escape from their current situation. After reading, the cover now represents a child who has many responsibilities, such as a donor, and is scared of her future.

I think the cover is from the perspective of a person in charge, possibly a guardian, portraying a girl who is a clone who is going to begin donating.

This cover places a focus on the author's name. This makes me think that the dark haired child pictured is of Asian descent. This brings in a construct of improving your life through hard work, since many Asians have traveled to other countries for a better life, which is supported by the image being a child running away.

This cover was perhaps made by a more broadly oriented company. By making the child pictured have brown hair, this widens the possibility of more people connecting with character since most people have dark hair.

9 comments:

  1. I was joking when I said you do too much but you really did haha. Your analysis of covers one and two is very logical and consistent with what can be seen in the visual cues the artists behind each chose to include. In cover one, I like your thought that the image of a girl, alone, and sitting on the floor of forest is very reminiscent of loneliness and seclusion. You're right that the girl is probably a portrayal Kathy's character, but I think it was to visualize the feelings of 'aloneness' Kathy has in the world as a whole as a clone, not at Hailsham where she had many friends. In cover 2 I thought it was funny that you thought she was Asian because for some reason I see that too. In this cover, I agree that before reading I would have seen escape, but after I reading and seeing that she is accepting of her future, I see a visual theme of confusion and fear.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am pretty sure you do not need to write about as much as you did. You used good analysis and did exactly what you were required to do (and more). However, everything you did was in regards to what she asked for. I would love to see you analyze in your own way. Be creative, be quirky, just don't be exactly what is expected; you are better than that.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sutton, this was some awesome analysis. I'm not gonna rag on you about writing too much like the two guys above did cause I'm a long winded person and I think when it comes to the quality of analysis you had it helps when you say everything that comes to your mind. I really really liked how you broke down the second cover because I struggled in understanding that cover. It was really interesting to consider the possibility of the girl portrayed to be of Asian descent and I think that you justified that claim extremely well. Quality blog post, good work!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your blog post was amazing! I loved the way you paid attention to every little detail especially how you described her clothes as modest in the first cover and explained how you got the impression that she was innocent because of the lack of makeup. I also liked your view on the second cover describing it with words like "child," and "escape", these are very different from the words I would describe it as but you explanation made me understand here you were coming from. I struggled with analyzing these two covers, so kudos to you.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Sutton, as always, your creativity and insightfulness amazes me. I really like your initial thoughts about each cover and the intended purposes. I agree with the "melancholic" tone that your pointed out about cover 1. I also agree that cover 4 is mysterious and introduces the theme of health and the human body. I think your analysis of cover 1 was interesting because of what you uncovered about Kathy H., that the expression on her face is due to the mystery and confusion of Hailsham. Keep doin' you girl, good job.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Wow, what a post. The organization of it made it super easy to read and understand. I also looked at cover one for a more in depth analysis and noticed similar things, mainly how the girl looks isolated. The detail that you went into each cover with really cool. I did not notice that cover four has barbed wire as the outside of the body, and I agree that it connects to the mystery of the novel. When I looked at cover two, I took it to be more about life moving fast and at times not being able to focus. I had never thought about relating it back to childhood and the childlike trait of running from fear, which is a really cool way to interpret it. Awesome post!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wowza this sure was dandy! Very well organized and some fine analysis. I like the way you pointed out the feeling of beeing sad or alone in the first cover. And how it's the feeling when something bad happens because I think that really highlights the tone of the cover. Good work

    ReplyDelete
  8. Well organized and super easy to follow. The analysis was done well and was also very thorough. I liked how you added the pictures into your post to make it easier to understand for those who may not have seen the original post.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I definite agree with comments from others about organization- this is a great way to think about approaching Paper 1 (of course, you'd need to put it all together into an essay). It did allow for a decent analysis; I wish you had provided a bit MORE analysis and big picture to little picture here, but an overall good response!

    ReplyDelete